In
the wake of Zimmerman verdict I have been musing on the issue of race and ethnicity
and how does it affect me and other browns. Biologically all humans are Homo
Sapiens and hence essentially similar at the core. However, people do not
interact based upon science or ethics but according to perceptions and
heuristics. Perceptions, in turn, are affected by historical, social and
cultural experiences among people of different races and ethnicities. United
States has a very traumatic history of persecution of Blacks through slavery
and discrimination through Jim Crow and discrimination and persecution of new
immigrants through xenophobia. Whites
in this country looked down upon colored people, black, brown and yellow as
inferior. Although things have improved after civil rights legislation and
outstanding progress made by the African American community, tensions and
suspicions remain on both sides; a few Whites still lament the loss of their
hegemony and continue to harbor stereotypes that associate blackness with crime
and depraved lifestyle and a few Blacks harbor a persistent feeling of
persecution that makes them more sensitive to even 'usual' altercations of
life. The white racists look down upon browns and yellows too, but Blacks bear
the brunt of Zimmerman type attacks because they are the most visible minority
and crime statistics, whatever may be the reasons, are stacked against them. However
“rolling up of car windows and accelerating pace when a colored person,
particularly a bearded or turbaned person”, although more common with blacks,
is not unique to them. Being surrounded or followed by an unfamiliar person in
an unknown or unfamiliar environment at an unfamiliar time may evoke a similar
response from anyone irrespective of race and ethnicity and the racial question
in America has become multicolored: there have been racist incidents between
blacks and yellows (1992 LA riots between Blacks and Koreans) and Hispanic and
blacks and browns (1987 Jersey City Dot buster hate crimes against Asian
Indians). Each group has its own stereotype of who is more aggressive and a
threat. Some of these stereotypes are based upon personal experiences, some on
the basis of crime statistics, some on the basis of media reports and some on
group tales that pass from person to person often getting a mythical character
to them. The outcome is overgeneralization.
In
the face of such ubiquitous prejudice and stereotyping, vigilantism of people
like Zimmerman becomes dangerous for all people of color. Even if Zimmerman had
felt threatened, he should not have gotten out of his car, especially when he
was advised by the police. He violated the civil rights of a young American of
free movement and provoked the youngster to have an altercation. While there
may be reasonable doubt about the altercation there is no doubt that the young
man was denied his right to move freely on public property. To prevent such
loss of young lives, we need a multipronged approach with sociological,
legislative and judicial action involving all races and ethnicities.
We
should study honestly and openly, these perceptions, stereotypes and their origin and heuristics that operationalize them
into serious and fatal outcomes as in Trayvon Martin case. First and foremost
we should become familiar ad knowledgeable about one another. Asian Indian
community has to begin getting involved because one day an Asian Indian child
could be victim of vigilantism.
No comments:
Post a Comment